Projects > Website Evaluation Project

Website Evaluation Exercise

QUICK QUIZ  (3 minutes)

How do we know if a website is reliable?

  •    Number your piece of scrap paper from 1 to 6.
  •    Open each of the webpages below.
  •   Would you use this website for research?
      •    Write Yes, No, or Unsure beside the number for each website:
                                     Yes--I'd use it.  The page looks reliable.
                                      No --I wouldn't use this page for research.  I don't trust it.
                                     Unsure--Can't decide.  Some features make me feel uneasy.
 

Websites
1.  Dwayne Medical Centre
2.  Parliament Hill
3.  White House
4.  Pampers
5.  Aspartame
6.  The Canadian Heritage Alliance

 

 

                   When it comes to doing homework, the Internet's
                   the first choice for Canadian students.
                   36% of secondary students believe that most
                   of the information found on the Internet is accurate
(Source: Young Canadians In A Wired World Survey, Media Awareness Network, 2001)

ASSIGNMENT

Group #1: Authority and Accuracy

Focus Question: Who has created this site?   Are they experts?
                             Can you trust the information they're presenting?

Look at both sites listed below and complete the assignment sheet.

Feline Reactions to Bearded Men
DHMO Site
 
 

Group #2:  Advocacy and Objectivity

Focus Question:  Does this site favour a particular point of view?
                              How objective is the information on this site?

Look at both sites listed below and complete the assignment sheet.

 Consumer Reports Online
Earthsave International
 
 

    Group #3:  Currency and Coverage

Focus Question:  What evidence can you find to determine how up-to-date this page is?
                              Does the page cover its topics as completely as it claims?

Look at both sites listed below and complete the assignment sheet.

CNN
Auto-by-Tel